Why does gene jounce the limb

On page sixty, the narrator Gene says, "Holding firmly to the trunk, I took a step toward. Although, while I was reading these novels, I may not have appreciated them at the time. Now as I am reflecting the themes and lessons that can be learned from the books, I am noticing just how great these books truly are. Just like all books, these two books carried important information and experiences that readers can learn from.

Even though these books are both fiction, that. Gene had very good reasons to push him out "Finny had put him up to it, to finish me fro good on the exam. He pushed him out of jealousy for two things. For athleticism, and for his popularity, and also for his ability to talk his way out of anything.. First, Finny was a very athletic person; however, Gene is just a normal average day person. Gene couldn't stand attempting to …show more content… When he and Gene had skipped dinner to go to the tree, they were caught when they were walking back.

All he did was talk to the teacher right there, and nothing ever came up about again. Another time was when Finny was at the headmaster's house for tea, he was wearing a tie as a belt, but the odd part was that it was the school tie. If gene thought for himself then the problem would have been resolved. But then again who said there ever was a problem, there isnt!

Gene is just making one up in his head! This proves the supports the inference that this book has mainly internal conflict. Andrew, I do believe the envy between Gene and Finny is the main reason Gene jounced the limb, because of how much denial Gene was in. To answer your first and third question, I think Gene will regret what he did to Finny, because guilt overpowers everything, but that won't stop Gene from trying to be on the top.

Throughout the summer, Gene was trying to figure out whether Finny envied him in return, which caused as Daniel said an internal conflict. Daniel, even though Gene may continue to focus on his improving in school, don't you think the guilt will soon take over? Monday, September 26, Chapters Why did Gene jounce the limb? It could have just been on impulse because of his jealousy towards Finny. Heather period 1. I think that Gene didn't intentionally meant to jounce the limb, he just did it without thinking.

One of the reasons why he might have wanted him to fall is so he would be out of his life or to get rid of him so he could pretend to be him. Afterward, he felt very guilty, so guilty that he had to tell Finny. I think he wore Finny's cloths to see what it would like to be Finny. When he tells Finny that it was all his fault, Finny doesn't want to believe it. Brendan Period 7. When Gene tells Finny that the accident was his fault, Finny wont listen to him.

I believe that Gene's actions on the tree were completely deliberate, but may have been subconsious. Gene, at this point, feels that he and Finny are unequal. Finny, to Gene, is a symbol of perfection and Gene envies him to the point where he wants to destroy him. I was not of the same quality as he Weeks later, when Gene visits Finny in Boston, he attempts at an apology.

After he tells Finny that the fall was his fault, Finny refuses to believe it. He doesnt understand the extent of Gene's admiration and obsession with him. When Finny says "I'm going to hit you if you don't sit down," 70 Gene's only response is to remind FInny that he can't even get up to reach him. At this point in the story, I'm starting to think that Gene is dangerous. I think he has the capability to really hurt Finny, more than he already has, physically and mentally.

He's already deeply hurt himself, mentally speaking. I predict that the remaining parts of the novel will prove Gene's mind to be tainted with an ever-growing unhealthy obsession. I believe Gene decided to where Finny's clothing because then it would almost be like him being finny himself. All of the jealousy Gene felt toward Finny has been erased, because now Gene has taken Finny's spot.

Finnys reaction to Genes confession was not a good one. It was so bad in fact the Gene felt forced to take back everything he said. Gene strikes me as very cowardly for doing this. He cant fess up to anything. I dont see why he has to be jealous of Finny either. After all, Gene is one of the best students and Finny is one of the best athletes. IT seems as if Genes jealousy is fueled by greed, like he wants to be the best at everything.

I think the the jouncing of the limb was planned by Gene but i don't think the outcome of it was. What i mean by this statement is that Gene wanted to scare Finny but didn't want to harm him in anyway. I think what he felt after the incident was like a shock of what had just happened. Gene didn't wish this to happen to Finny but he just wanted to scare him a little. I think Gene wore Finny's clothes because he felt bad for what happened and missed Finny. I think this was a way of showing his love for Finny.

I think that when Gene finally told the truth to Finny, Finny didn't want to believe the truth. Finny didn't want to believe that his best friend would want to harm him in anyway. I believe that Gene jouncing the limb was an impulsive act.

He had just come under the realization that Finny was not out to get him. Gene had been under the assumption that Finny was bad for so long that it just happened. If he had, had time to think about his actions then he probably would not have done that. This is because immediately after the fact he regrets what had happened. Kelsey per. The jouncing of the limb was definitely an impulsive act by Gene.

Him and Finny are the best of friends, but Gene was extremely jealous of Finny. Gene got to his boiling point when they went to the beach and slept over.

Gene did very poorly on his test that he should have studied for. The jealousy got to him when they were on the tree; that caused him to jounce the limb impulsively. Gene might have wanted to see Finny fall because he manipulated Gene into coming to the tree with him.

I think he might want the attention of everyone else. It could even be that he feels really bad that he has done something that bad to his best friend; to symbolize how sorry he was. He was just forcing himself to think that wind or maybe even a squirrel jostled the limb to make him fall.

He wanted to see Finny get scared. However, I dont think he really wanted him to get hurt like he did. Gene was tired of Finny being so perfect in every way. He wanted to see him mess up or look dumb just once. He really wasnt thinking about the aftermath once gene started shaking the tree.

He was justthinking of himself and how he wanted to be perfect. And I dont think that finny actually believed Genj when he told him. He didnt want to believe i.

I think that Gene jouncing the limb was a subconcious decision. After it happened Gene was shocked and very guilty about it. Gene might have wanted to see Finny fall because he feels like it is a contest between the two of them to see who was better. When he found out the news that Finny was lucky to be walking and would never play sports again, Gene started crying as if the doctor was talking about him.

I'm not sure why Gene put on Finny's clothes. It might be because he wanted to feel like Finny and maybe act like him more. Or maybe he wanted to have him there, so putting on his clothes brought him back.

He says that Finny wore Gene's clothes because he would just pick something up and wear it, so he might want to be like Finny. Molly, period 7. Andrew Period 7 I think Gene did plan out the jouncing of the limb. He wanted to see Finny get scared but not get hurt.

He didnt want to believe it. It was his best freind after all. He was just thinking of himself and how he wanted to be perfect. They are best friends and I think they both knew that they wanted to keep this relashionship so in my opinion both wanted to pretend like this was an accident. Finny was clearly jounced off the limb by Gene, but I highly doubt that Gene did this purposely. There is no hesitation in my mind when I say that Gene finds the relationship between him and Finny a competition.

Gene is undeniably jealous of Finny but I do not think jealousy was the motive for Gene's actions. In the scene where Gene jounced the limb, he didn't include any other details about what was happening other then him bending his knees and jumping off into the river afterward. Since this is a 1st person narrated story, I would expect that if Gene was conscience , he would include details like what was running through his mind at that point in time.

The jouncing was a guileless subconscious act. Immediately after Finny has fallen, Gene is so shaken and aghast that he jumps into the river.

If he jounced the limb on purpose, he would not have jumped into the river while thinking, "every trace of my fear of this forgotten. From immediately jumping off the tree into the river, Gene is sincerely surprised and scared. After reading the scene of Gene trying on Finny's clothes over and over again, I am still mystified about what the author is trying to convey. Gene puts on Finny's clothes because he is obviously jelous of him.

My thought is that the clothing symbolizes leadership and power, everything Gene wants to be. But when Gene puts on Finny's clothing, he realizes that he is not some superhero, or "character out of daydreams. After trying on Finny's clothing, Gene says, "I would never stumble through the confusions of my own character again. Since Finny placed so much trust in Gene to be his best friend, he doesn't believe that Gene would hurt him.

In this case Finny is naive to think the best of Gene. Finny doesn't comprehend the fact that no one has as pure as a heart as he does and therefore he doesn't want to believe what Gene is telling him. Alice Ni Period 7. I think that the decision to jounce the limb and make Finny fall was an impulsive decision, rather than something Gene had planned out. If it was planned out, I think Gene would have known the consequences, and known what was going to happen, therefore Gene would have at least given it a second to stand there and admire his work.

Instead Gene rushed out to see if Finny was all right. Gene would naturally want Finny to fall with everything going on with them lately. Gene was so jealous of Finny, and the jealousy just got so bad that it caused Gene to want to do something horrible to Finny. After the fall, then Gene automatically realizes what he has done, and is completely shocked.

He then jumps in after his friend to see if he is all right. I even had his humorous expression in my face, his sharp, optimistic awareness. Jouncing the tree limb was an impulsive action for Gene. At that moment his jealousy got the better of him, he was up on the limb that he had always dreaded and even countless number of jumps did not distill the fear of jumping. There is significance to the fact that after hearing the thud of Finny's body against the riverbank did Gene feel at ease with jumping form the tree.

The juxtaposition of Finny and Gene here is that Finny; the true friend wants to jump side by side at the same time like if they'd face everything together, but Gene's illogical hatred toward Finny at that moment compels him to act without thinking of the dire consequences. The fact that Gene tried to forget who he was and what he had done after the accident shows some morality but it is disturbing that while trying to forget himself he tried to become Finny.

No one wants to believe that someone they love and care for could possibly try to purposely hurt them. Its like Finny would take a bullet for Gene, but all along it would be Gene who shot the gun. Gene jounced the limb on purpose but he wasn't planing to do it when Finny sugested they climb the tree and jump together. Gene had a lot of crazy ideas swirling around in his head and that led to some anger toward Finny, and when he saw Finny standing out there on that branch something from somewhere inside him told him to jouce that branch.

If he had time to think about it he wouldn't have jounced the branch because he's smart kid and he would have thought about the consequences, but when he was up on that limb his instinct kicked in. The words exchanged between Finny and Gene before the incident show that Gene was wrong about Finny all along.

Finny wasn't trying to be better than Gene in every way possible he was a true friend. Gene either didn't accept this or still didn't belive this until a while after the fall from the tree, when he realizes what he's done and feels that he has to apologize. Immediatly after the fall however Gene feels like has accomplished something and the good feeling from this accomplishment took over his fear of jumping out of the tree.

Later when Gene puts on Finny's clothes he is symbolizing how now he feels equal to Finny. So equal that they can wear the same clothes. When Gene confesses that he shook the limb on purpose and Finny tells him not to say that Finny is in denial. Finny doesn't want to accept the fact that a kid that he thought was his best friend would want to harm him in such a bad way.

I think Gene jouced the limb not consciously. I think that it was his jealousy of Finny that did it. The jealousy in this book is like and alternative personality that Gene doesn't do things consciously. Its like the jealous personality comes out and takes over his body and brain, and Gene doesn't have an recalection of what he did when hes in this state.

When he jounced the limb i believe that the jealousy did it and wanted to scare Finny and perhaps make him fall. Also i believe that this alternate personality causes something tragic to happen to Finny :P - andrew. I think that jouncing the limb was not a planned action by Gene, but rather it was imvoluntary. Many different things were going on throughout Gene's head at the time, which probably caused him to jounce the limb due to the fact that he was not focused on the situation at hand.

Other students have posted that he might have been "posessed" of some sort, which I can agree with - Gene was certainly not himself when this happened. All he did was talk to the teacher right there, and nothing ever came up about again. Again, Phineas explained to the headmaster, that wearing the school tie as a belt, contributed to the war effort. All he had to do was explain it, and he never got in trouble again. Gene probably wished he had the ability to do that; however, he knew that only Finny could do it, and with such ease.

They spent the night on the beach and when they got back Gene fails his triginometry test. Later Gene claims that Finny did it on purpose to lower his grade and make Finny look good. As you can see, Gene had much reason to push Finny out of the tree.